Chief John Rodger
2008 – Current

Chief Edward Hudak
Chief Edward Hudak
2003 – 2008
Chief Kevin White
Chief Kevin White
2002 – 2003
Chief Edward Tilton
Chief Edward Tilton
1998 – 2002
Chief Barry Henderson
Chief Barry Henderson
1988 – 1998
Chief Theodore E. Polhamus
Chief Theodore E. Polhamus
1973 – 1988
Chief John J. Hummel
Chief John J. Hummel
1971 – 1973
Chief Herbert Kinch
Chief Herbert Kinch
1966 – 1971
Chief Lawrence Coman
Chief Lawrence Coman
1954 – 1966
Chief Raymond Barton
Chief Raymond Barton
1953 – 1954
Chief Clifford Dunphy
Chief Clifford Dunphy
1938 – 1953
Chief George McIntyre
Chief George McIntyre
1930 – 1938
1924 – 1930       Chief John A. Smith
1911 – 1923         Chief David Ramsey
** – 1911               Chief George Wright
1879 – *                Chief William Tooker
1872 – 1879        Chief George Wright
1865 – 1871         Chief James L. Bodwell
1858 – 1864           No Record

* 1891: Last Rahway papers available noted that Chief William Tooker still in office.
** 1911: First Rahway paper available that lists Chief as George Wright.